The Misconception About Being Close to the Customer
When we describe the difference between incumbent and insurgent thinking to groups of business leaders, sales and marketing folks are usually the first to identify themselves as insurgents. They point to the fact that they’re customer-facing, market-facing, always testing things, constantly in motion.
But here’s the problem with that logic: just because you’re busy and close to customers doesn’t mean you’re operating like an insurgent.
Most sales and marketing teams use the same tactics, hit the same channels, and follow similar rhythms as their competitors. Everyone’s zigging in the same direction. So no one’s creating real distance. Activity is not the same as breakthrough.
In this episode of The Insurgent Mindset, we challenge a common misconception about commercial teams: that proximity to the customer automatically equals insurgency.
From Traditional Playbook to Insurgent Breakthrough
Consider what happened in pharmaceutical sales in the late 1980s. Every pharma company followed the exact same playbook. Sales reps called on individual doctors, detailed products, dropped off prescription samples, and took physicians out to dinner. Everybody did the same things. So the competition became a marginal fight for market share won mostly by having the blockbuster drug, rather than by selling differently.
Then the industry started to shift. HMOs and large buying groups were growing, and some companies recognized this early. They created national accounts management organizations, also commonly known as Managed Markets, not for government contracts, which already existed, but for commercial buyers. That was actually insurgent.
Suddenly, these teams were no longer selling to individual doctors. They were selling business value propositions to sophisticated buyers with formularies and purchasing committees. Companies brought in outside experts to train their salespeople because no one within the organization knew how to do this kind of selling. They were moving away from what traditional pharmaceutical sales looked like.
The lesson: breakthrough happens when you recognize the game itself has changed and you need to play it differently.
When “The Stupidest Idea” Becomes Breakthrough Strategy
The problem with most sales and marketing functions is that they’re stuck on what “should” work. They use the proven channels, work with established agencies, and follow familiar tactics.
In one innovation exercise with a client in the insurance underwriting business, the group was asked: “What’s the stupidest thing you could do to engage your customers?”
Someone said, “Write them handwritten letters.”
Everyone laughed. It seemed ridiculous. But then the CEO stopped and thought about it. He realized their sales effort was the same as everyone else’s in the industry. Everyone was going digital, investing in marketing automation. What if they did something different? What if they zigged when everyone else was zagging?
The thing is, when no one else in your market is doing something, that might not be stupid. That might be an opening.
This gets at what insurgent selling really looks like. It’s not about asking “How do we do more?” It’s asking:
- How do we create engagement that our competitors aren’t considering?
- How do we organize resources to get 3x or 5x leverage instead of marginal gains?
- How do we challenge the assumptions about how selling “should” be done?
Rethinking Who Does the Selling
One of the most underutilized insurgent strategies is actually pretty straightforward: get more people involved in selling.
A professional services firm had concentrated all its sales activities on a small, specialized team. Everyone else delivered client work. It was a clear division of labor that seemed to make sense.
But then they started asking questions. They had hundreds of people interacting with potential customers every day—receptionists, project managers, and technical specialists. What if everyone became part of the sales effort?
So they did it. They made selling everyone’s job and built sales skills into every role across the organization. The result was that they multiplied their sales engine without adding headcount. Instead of hundreds of sales conversations per year, they were having thousands.
This way of thinking challenges a deeply held assumption—that sales requires a particular personality type or specialized skill set. Insurgent organizations reject that. They recognize everyone has a role in creating market engagement, even if it’s not directly selling products.
What Insurgent Marketers Do Differently
Marketing has changed a lot in the last decade, mostly because of digital channels and all the data available now. But more tools haven’t automatically led to more creativity.
Insurgent marketers make their impact by challenging how things are done in their category. They disrupt through tone, storytelling, channel selection, and bold positioning.
Look at how Dollar Shave Club went after Gillette. If you watch their early videos next to Gillette’s ads from the same period, the contrast is striking. Gillette had this super polished production—dark, muted colors, very disciplined brand messaging from what was clearly an expensive agency. Dollar Shave Club filmed guys in a warehouse driving forklifts around. Bright, irreverent. And their message was essentially “why are you paying for all that expensive advertising?” Every detail was different. Every assumption flipped.
Or Liquid Death—a water company that packages their product like beer in tall cans with the tagline “Murder Your Thirst.” Their ads are hilarious and provocative. They’re not leaning into wellness messaging like every other water brand. They decided to be edgy instead.
These brands didn’t win with bigger budgets. They won by refusing to follow the playbook everyone else was using.
The Power of Co-Creation
One of the most underutilized insurgent strategies: getting customers themselves involved as amplifiers and validators.
Blockbuster spent millions on advertising. Netflix grew through word of mouth.
Traditional automakers built out dealership networks. Tesla grew through owner evangelism.
When your customers are so satisfied that they become your salespeople, you’ve created something powerful. The feedback loop gets faster because customers are telling you directly what works and what doesn’t. Your product development gets better because you’re designing with customer input from the beginning, not filtering everything through layers of organization. And your reach extends without burning more marketing dollars—customers are doing the work for you.
This is what happened with Netflix’s DVD-by-mail service and later with Tesla. Customers weren’t just buying. They were recruiting. That’s a different growth curve entirely.
Building the Insurgent Muscle Inside Incumbent Organizations
Insurgent tactics come naturally to challengers. They have nothing to lose. But incumbents face more friction—silos, risk aversion, process rigidity, all the gravity of “how we’ve always done it.”
That said, breakthroughs are still possible when you’re intentional about it. Three levers consistently make the difference:
Rethink the metrics. Traditional KPIs usually reinforce traditional behavior. If you measure what everyone else measures, you’ll optimize what everyone else optimizes for. Insurgent teams look at different things—customer lifetime value instead of just transaction revenue, growth from new offerings instead of just existing products, and cost-to-impact ratios that show where you’re getting real leverage. These metrics force different thinking about how you deploy resources.
Reengineer the operating model. Sales and marketing need flexibility to experiment quickly, deploy resources in unconventional ways, question the role of agencies and technologies, and collaborate across the organization. When silos come down, customer insights flow into product development and operations. The whole organization becomes more responsive.
Challenge every assumption. Every playbook is built on assumptions that were probably true at some point but might not be anymore. Things like “our agency knows best,” “we have to use these channels,” or “this is how customers buy from us.” Insurgent teams flip these assumptions on purpose to see what opens up. When you do this consistently, it becomes a capability, not just a one-off exercise.
Lessons From an Unexpected Campaign
The 2025 New York City Democratic mayoral primary is a good case study in insurgent marketing, even though it’s politics and not business.
Zohran Mamdani, a 33-year-old state assemblyman, beat Andrew Cuomo—a former three-term governor with an extensive political machine, resources, name recognition, and decades of credibility—in the 2025 Democratic Primary and General Election. Cuomo’s win was supposed to be inevitable.
But Mamdani didn’t follow the traditional political playbook. He didn’t rely on big donors, traditional media, or power brokers. He went directly to where voters were—in the streets, on subway platforms, at local events. His team operated more like a startup: decentralized, mission-driven, and empowered to act without waiting for approval.
Starting with just five organizers in the primary, his campaign engaged more than 50,000 canvassers, raised money from 27,000 grassroots donors, and had direct conversations with 1.5 million New Yorkers.
His communication was equally different. While Cuomo used traditional campaign advertising, Mamdani used short-form videos on TikTok with clear policy proposals voters could understand immediately: freeze rents, free city buses, free childcare, and free city-owned grocery stores. No jargon. No lengthy policy papers.
Everything was at the street level. Every assumption about how campaigns work got flipped. And the incumbent couldn’t adjust fast enough.
For sales and marketing leaders: what would happen if you applied the same principles to your market?
The Future of Insurgent Commercial Functions
Markets keep shifting—AI, new business models, and changing customer expectations. The gap between incumbents and insurgents is only going to get wider. The organizations that win will be the ones that can blend creativity with analytics, use constraints to fuel innovation, create leverage instead of just relying on scale, and bring customers into the value creation process.
Breakthrough doesn’t come from doubling down on what’s always worked. It comes from rethinking the whole approach.
That’s what defines an insurgent sales and marketing organization. It’s a commercial engine built to challenge assumptions, differentiate in ways that matter, and create value that competitors struggle to replicate.
The real question isn’t whether your teams are busy or customer-facing. It’s whether they’re operating differently enough to create distance from competitors. Are they challenging the assumptions everyone else just accepts? Are they building leverage that multiplies impact without multiplying cost?
Because when everyone has access to the same tools and channels, the only enduring advantage is thinking and operating in ways your competitors haven’t considered.
For more insights on building an insurgent mindset in your organization, contact Matthew Tice (mtice@insurgencegroup.com) or Rondo Moses (rmoses@insurgencegroup.com).
Listen to “The Insurgent Mindset” on Apple, Spotify and Youtube.