Executive Brief
Customer Proximity

Why Human Experience Becomes More Valuable as AI Scales

Discover why human insight, customer proximity, and judgment remain critical advantages as AI transforms customer experience.

The marketing industry Si Elliott entered more than 20 years ago bears little resemblance to the one he operates in today. Early in his career, much of the work revolved around printed materials, physical retail displays and production processes that now appear extraordinarily slow. Artwork could take more than an hour to transmit to a printer, images had to be located and licensed individually, and almost every campaign contained a significant print component.

Successive waves of technology steadily changed that model. Social media created entirely new channels. Broadband and cloud technologies dramatically accelerated production and distribution. Digital platforms increased the number of ways organisations could reach customers while simultaneously increasing the speed at which those communications were expected to be produced.

Elliott, who has spent his career in marketing and customer experience and founded the customer experience consultancy Fabricx, sees the current wave of artificial intelligence as different in its intensity. The industry once appeared to experience meaningful disruption every five or six years. The equivalent degree of change can now arrive within five or six weeks.

Designers who spent years developing technical skills can now perform some tasks through a button inside Adobe. Entrepreneurs can create websites, produce content, develop early versions of applications and access specialist knowledge without assembling the teams that would have been required even a few years ago. The cost of turning an idea into something that can be tested in the market has fallen dramatically.

For Elliott, however, the most important tension created by this technological acceleration is not between old technology and new technology. It lies between rapidly improving machines and human beings whose underlying psychological needs have changed much less.

Technology moves faster than people do

Customers have access to more information, more channels and more digital services than at any previous point, but Elliott argues that they remain fundamentally human in how they process the world. Decisions continue to be shaped by habit, emotion, experience, anxiety, social influence and cognitive biases, even when those decisions occur through increasingly sophisticated digital interfaces.

This matters because organisations can become so focused on data, conversion and efficiency that the individual behind the information disappears from view. Marketers talk about segments, funnel stages and conversion rates, while customer service operations increasingly measure speed, cost and resolution. Those tools are useful, but Elliott sees a danger when they become substitutes for understanding the person on the other side of the interaction.

The same principle applies in business-to-business markets, where purchasing decisions are often described as more rational than consumer choices. The commercial context may differ, but people who worry about making the wrong choice, want to justify their decisions to colleagues, and bring their own experiences and biases to the process still make the decision.

Elliott therefore returns repeatedly to a deceptively simple question: who is on the other side of the fence, and what is important to them? Answering it requires organisations to move beyond what is easiest to measure and understand the emotional and behavioural realities of the people they serve.

That orientation also changes the way businesses think about value. Rather than asking primarily how a customer can be moved through a process more efficiently, Elliott encourages organisations to ask how effectively they are serving that person. Businesses that serve customers well create stronger relationships, repeat purchasing, loyalty and advocacy, all of which become harder to build when interactions are treated principally as transactions to be optimised.

Automate the process, not the moments that need humanity

Elliott strongly praises the capability that AI has created. For entrepreneurs, AI has substantially lowered the barriers to starting a business because technology can increasingly provide skills and resources that once required a network of specialists. For larger organisations, AI creates opportunities to increase efficiency and expand the capacity of employees who are equipped with new tools to do more.

His concern is that efficiency can become the objective rather than the means.

Customer experience contains moments where automation can remove friction without reducing value. It also contains moments where customers need empathy, explanation, reassurance, or simply the ability to feel heard. Treating those situations as equivalent can produce an efficient process that creates a poorer experience.

Elliott points to Klarna’s highly publicised move towards AI-supported customer service as an illustration of the risk he sees when organisations allow the efficiency argument to move too far ahead of the customer experience. His broader point is not that AI should be removed from customer service. Technology can make customer service employees more capable, just as power tools make a skilled tradesperson more productive, but increasing the capability of a person is different from assuming that the person no longer contributes value.

His own experience of being stranded after Heathrow Airport closed following a fire at a power station illustrates the distinction. For more than a day, he could interact only through an application while flight arrangements repeatedly changed. Even if a human operator could not have solved the underlying disruption, speaking to someone who acknowledged the situation and explained what was happening would have changed the experience because the value required at that moment was partly emotional rather than transactional.

Elliott uses healthcare to make the same point in a different setting. If a robotic surgeon could perform a procedure more accurately, a patient may be perfectly comfortable with greater automation because the outcome matters more than emotional connection while the patient is unconscious. After the procedure, when the same patient is disoriented, uncomfortable, and trying to understand what happens next, reassurance from a nurse may carry substantial value.

The management challenge is therefore not to decide whether an organisation should automate. It is to understand the customer journey with enough granularity to determine where automation improves the experience and where it removes something customers genuinely value.

Customer experience is built in the details.

Elliott sees exceptional customer experience as an accumulation of often-small decisions rather than a single dramatic intervention. Organisations need clarity about the journey they are trying to create and then enough attention to detail to improve the moments within it.

His example of a Major League Soccer club demonstrates the breadth of that thinking. The stadium experience was designed around the customer from its earliest stages rather than treating experience as something to be added after the physical infrastructure was completed. Sightlines from surrounding streets helped connect the ground with the city. Local food businesses became vendors inside the venue. Food aromas were deliberately incorporated into the environment rather than extracted from it. Acoustic design contributed to the atmosphere, while technology made transactions faster and reduced friction.

The experience also began before the team played its first game. An application was launched early so that supporters could begin engaging with the club before the first competitive event. On match days, entertainment and food encouraged people to arrive before kick-off and remain engaged beyond the central product of the football itself.

For Elliott, this provides an important lesson because the organisation cannot control the final score. It can control many of the surrounding conditions that determine whether attending the match remains a rewarding experience even when the team loses.

That principle extends beyond sport. Businesses often define the customer experience too narrowly around the primary transaction while overlooking what happens before it, after it, and in the pauses around it. A delay, a queue or a period of waiting is not automatically a failure if the surrounding experience creates connection or enjoyment. Conversely, eliminating every pause may remove parts of an experience that customers value for reasons the organisation has never examined.

The quality of customer experience therefore depends partly on understanding which forms of friction customers dislike and which experiences only appear inefficient when viewed from an operational perspective.

Customer experience cannot belong to one department.

Elliott argues that organisations often put substantial effort into outward-facing customer initiatives while underinvesting in the internal work required to deliver them consistently.

A customer journey crosses organisational boundaries. Marketing may create the promise, sales may begin the relationship, operations may deliver the product, and customer service may encounter the problems. If those functions work from different assumptions about what matters to the customer, the experience fragments regardless of the quality of the original strategy.

One of Elliott’s practical recommendations for marketers is to spend time with the customer service team. The questions and frustrations appearing repeatedly in customer service interactions can reveal gaps that marketing teams cannot see from campaign data alone. A message that appears clear internally may repeatedly confuse customers, while a minor feature from the organisation’s perspective may be responsible for disproportionate frustration.

Zappos represents the opposite approach in Elliott’s thinking because the organisation built a widely understood customer experience philosophy into the operating culture. Employees were given considerable freedom in how they dealt with customers, including spending extensive time on calls and, in some cases, directing a customer to a competitor when Zappos could not provide what the customer needed.

The significance of that approach lies less in any particular service gesture than in the internal alignment supporting it. Employees understood what the organisation was trying to deliver and could make decisions consistent with that objective without depending on a rigid script.

For executives, customer experience therefore becomes an operating-model issue as much as a marketing issue. The organisation needs a common language, shared expectations and enough connection between functions for the customer to experience one business rather than a sequence of internal departments.

Bring the customer into the strategy.

Elliott places particular emphasis on co-creation because customers tend to value things more highly when they have participated in creating them. Behavioural science describes this through the IKEA effect, where people can place disproportionate value on something partly because they contributed effort to its construction.

The principle extends beyond flat-pack furniture. Personalised products, customised shoes and participative service models give customers a role in shaping the outcome, creating a different relationship from simply receiving something designed entirely on their behalf.

Elliott applies the same thinking to his own work with clients. Rather than receiving a brief, disappearing to develop the answer and returning with a finished solution, he prefers processes in which the client participates in developing the work. That collaboration introduces more perspectives while increasing ownership of the eventual outcome.

Customer co-creation follows similar logic. Wherever the industry and regulatory context allow it, Elliott believes customers should be brought into product development, experience design and even strategic thinking earlier than organisations typically involve them.

Direct questioning is not always sufficient because what customers say they do and what they actually do can differ materially. Elliott therefore values ethnographic approaches that allow organisations to observe behaviour in real settings. Senior leaders working on a strategic problem can learn a great deal by watching customers interact with a product, service or environment rather than relying exclusively on reports describing those interactions.

Front-loading that insight also changes the economics of innovation. Discovering a fundamental weakness while a proposition is still being shaped is far less costly than identifying the same issue after the organisation has invested heavily in bringing it to market.

In an AI world, being human becomes a form of differentiation.

The growing abundance of AI-generated output leads Elliott to an interesting conclusion about where differentiation may increasingly come from. If organisations use similar technologies to generate similar forms of competent, polished content, the distinctly human characteristics that technology tends to smooth away may become more valuable.

Elliott expects some audiences to place greater value on knowing that content comes from a real person. Imperfection can become a signal of authenticity because a hesitation, an unusual perspective or an unscripted moment demonstrates that the communication has not been optimised into the same polished form as everything else.

He sees the same principle applying more broadly to brands. Businesses should use technology aggressively where it removes unnecessary work or improves capability, but the savings created through automation can be reinvested in the parts of the experience where people add disproportionate value.

For marketers trying to stand apart, Elliott’s advice begins with being human and being unique. Individual experience, perspective, accumulated knowledge and personal interpretation are difficult to replicate precisely because they have been developed through a particular life and career. AI can help someone express those ideas, but relying on the technology to supply the ideas themselves risks pushing organisations towards increasingly similar outputs.

Having a point of view consequently becomes more valuable. Not everybody will agree with it, and Elliott sees no reason they should. Distinctiveness requires enough confidence to express a perspective rather than continually optimising communication towards something nobody could reasonably disagree with.

Curiosity also becomes essential because the underlying environment will continue changing. Elliott has spent more than two decades in an industry repeatedly reshaped by technology and believes the current pace makes intellectual curiosity and genuine enjoyment of the work increasingly important. Constant disruption becomes exhausting when it is experienced purely as a threat, while the same change can create energy for people motivated by experimentation and discovery.

Keep the Customer Human

For Elliott, the starting point for CEOs is an understanding of how people actually think. Behavioural economics and behavioural science matter because employees, customers, investors and other stakeholders are not perfectly rational actors processing information objectively. They bring biases, emotions, previous experiences and social considerations into the decisions they make.

A sophisticated customer strategy therefore requires more than better technology or more data. Leaders need a grounded understanding of human behaviour and a mechanism for ensuring the customer remains represented in senior decision-making.

As AI expands the range of interactions that organisations can automate, that customer perspective becomes more important rather than less. Technology can accelerate processes, reduce costs and give employees capabilities that would have been difficult to imagine only a few years ago, but those advantages create value only when they improve the experience of the person receiving them.

Elliott’s argument is ultimately one of balance. Businesses should exploit the extraordinary capability technology provides while becoming much more deliberate about the moments they choose not to automate. In a market increasingly filled with efficient systems, polished AI-generated communication and scalable digital interactions, human connection may become one of the experiences customers notice precisely because it is becoming less common.

What Happens When Technology Moves Faster Than People Do?

Simon Elliott explores how leaders can use AI to increase capability and efficiency without losing the human insight, connection, and judgment that shape exceptional customer experiences.

Listen to “The Insurgent Mindset” podcast on Apple, Spotify, and YouTube.

Or contact us at mtice@insurgencegroup.com for more information.

Share this insight

Start a Conversation

Administrator preview. Public activation is pending GHL policy links and submission checks.

Loading the contact form…

Suggest a Topic or Guest