By Rondo Moses | November 2026
A few months ago, I wrote about how Walgreens lost roughly $100 billion in value and compared it to CVS. While Walgreens kept trying to make its old drugstore model work, CVS embarked on an ambitious strategy to move up the healthcare value chain, acquiring Caremark, a pharmacy benefit manager (PBM), in 2007 and the insurance company Aetna in 2018. That was my example of a real strategic pivot, a company changing where and how it competes, not just adding capabilities around the edges.
This week CVS announced it is reconfiguring that pivot. The company plans to separate its retail pharmacy operations from its insurance, pharmacy benefit management, and other healthcare services businesses. Aetna and Caremark will remain together, but the retail pharmacy division of the integrated healthcare model I pointed to as the smarter path is being separated. According to CEO David Joyner, “We’re basically taking what I believe is one great company and making it two.” The separation is expected to be completed in early 2028.
So was I wrong about CVS?
Partly. I was right to recognize CVS’s willingness to challenge the traditional pharmacy model and adapt. Where my analysis fell short was treating its integrated structure as the logical destination rather than another strategic configuration whose advantages would need to be continually tested.
CVS’s pivot was not necessarily a mistake. In the years when Walgreens stood still, expanding up the healthcare value chain was a defensible strategic response to changing industry economics. But the resulting integrated model now faces a different set of pressures: regulatory scrutiny, questions about whether common ownership creates sufficient economic value, and the possibility that greater strategic focus could benefit the separate businesses. The assumptions that justified integration deserve to be tested against today’s economics, not those of 2018.
Considering Walgreens and CVS side by side, I see two companies confronting the same challenge but responding differently.
Walgreens struggled to adapt. It treated its pharmacy network as a permanent advantage long after convenience strengthened the case for mail order, online delivery, and integrated care. The store footprint that once won no longer provided the leverage it needed.
CVS adapted. Now it must adapt again. It made the bold move Walgreens wouldn’t, but its integrated structure eventually faced a new economic test.
One company struggled to move beyond the model that made it successful. The other is now reconsidering how much of its transformed model needs to remain under one roof. Neither “stay put” nor “integrate everything” was the real answer, because neither was ever going to be a permanent solution. My Walgreens piece understated that part, and the CVS breakup makes it impossible to ignore.
There’s an important lesson here for anyone running a business built on a big structural bet. Your model, integrated or focused, centralized or spun out, is not a decision you make once. It is a position you must keep re-evaluating against the economics as they are, not as they were when you chose. The discipline required isn’t picking the right structure. It’s having the courage to challenge existing assumptions about the structure you picked, including the seemingly smart, celebrated move that everyone, me included, held up as the example to follow.
I still see CVS as the healthier case here. It is splitting up from a position of relative strength, after a quarter of higher earnings and raised guidance, rather than acting from weakness. Most incumbents never experience that version of this decision, because the hardest structure to question is the one that used to work. Walgreens learned that the hard way. CVS, this week, chose to learn it on its own terms.
I stand by what I wrote about Walgreens. But CVS has sharpened the lesson: the goal isn’t simply to make a bold strategic pivot. It’s to remain willing to challenge that pivot before the structure it created becomes a constraint.
Are you as willing to challenge the strategy that made you successful as you were to challenge the strategy it replaced?